ProSoundWeb Community

Sound Reinforcement - Forums for Live Sound Professionals - Your Displayed Name Must Be Your Real Full Name To Post In The Live Sound Forums => LAB: The Classic Live Audio Board => Topic started by: Bob Cap on January 23, 2019, 06:43:15 PM

Title: Replace some gear
Post by: Bob Cap on January 23, 2019, 06:43:15 PM
We had a small accident with our truck last week. a guy in a pickup truck tried to pass us on an icy road, lost control, hit the back of my truck and threw us in quite a bit of a spin back & forth. Got it back under control and discovered the rails inside the box had ripped off the wall and quite a bit of gear flew around.

We lost 9 of the 10 RCF ART500a speakers. The LS9/32 is trashed. Our wireless rack of 10 AT3000 wireless systems is questionable and several road cases are broken....

Now I am working with the insurance co...

I need some suggestions for replacements:

Monitors - 10 - 15 x 2 self powered
Mixer - replace the LS9/32
Wireless - What to replace the AT3000 series.

Throw me a few suggestions if you were doing this what would you get.

Thanks much

Bob Cap
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Bob Stone on January 23, 2019, 07:15:16 PM
Better road cases...just sayin lol
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Tim McCulloch on January 23, 2019, 07:48:42 PM
Better road cases...just sayin lol

Or mo' betta load control, to go with the replacement gear.  Just sayin'.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Tim McCulloch on January 23, 2019, 07:55:33 PM
We had a small accident with our truck last week. a guy in a pickup truck tried to pass us on an icy road, lost control, hit the back of my truck and threw us in quite a bit of a spin back & forth. Got it back under control and discovered the rails inside the box had ripped off the wall and quite a bit of gear flew around.

We lost 9 of the 10 RCF ART500a speakers. The LS9/32 is trashed. Our wireless rack of 10 AT3000 wireless systems is questionable and several road cases are broken....

Now I am working with the insurance co...

I need some suggestions for replacements:

Monitors - 10 - 15 x 2 self powered
Mixer - replace the LS9/32
Wireless - What to replace the AT3000 series.

Throw me a few suggestions if you were doing this what would you get.

Thanks much

Bob Cap

Sorry to hear you lost some gear but it's great that you/your crew were not injured.

Insurance settlement aside, what would you buy to upgrade this rig, and what's your pain point (budget)?

NAMM is coming up this week, might see what is new and exciting.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Riley Casey on January 23, 2019, 09:27:41 PM
Can't resist my usual refrain.  Buy the same things you can rent more of quickly and easily.  Unless you're an entirely stand alone operation in an isolated market you will reap benefits from being able to get more wedges / speakers / amps, whatever from your competitors if you have similar inventories.  A bit less so with consoles UNLESS you use digital stage boxes then the same factors come into play.  Your inventory of course becomes much more re-rentable as well.

Other than that why do you want powered wedges?  It means twice as many cables on the stage, it means more weight in the boxes that get moved the most without wheels, it means a hundred plus components to fail in the box rather than five or ten.  I get powered boxes for subs and maybe flown speakers where cable length and low impedance loads start to become an issue but not wedges.

...

Throw me a few suggestions if you were doing this what would you get.

Thanks much

Bob Cap
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: brian maddox on January 23, 2019, 09:56:23 PM

Other than that why do you want powered wedges?  It means twice as many cables on the stage, it means more weight in the boxes that get moved the most without wheels, it means a hundred plus components to fail in the box rather than five or ten.  I get powered boxes for subs and maybe flown speakers where cable length and low impedance loads start to become an issue but not wedges.

^^THIS!!!!!  I do NOT understand the fascination with powered boxes in general, but especially not for wedges.

As to a passive wedge choice, the d&b MAX2 is the newer version of the Max 15.  Sounds amazing and can be powered by any amplifier which makes it mix and match a little better with whatever else you have in your inventory.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Geert Friedhof on January 23, 2019, 11:04:50 PM
LS9 > M32
Art500 > NX32, TT25-cxa
AT3000 > QLXD
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Bob Stone on January 23, 2019, 11:26:11 PM
Can't resist my usual refrain.  Buy the same things you can rent more of quickly and easily.  Unless you're an entirely stand alone operation in an isolated market you will reap benefits from being able to get more wedges / speakers / amps, whatever from your competitors if you have similar inventories.  A bit less so with consoles UNLESS you use digital stage boxes then the same factors come into play.  Your inventory of course becomes much more re-rentable as well.

Other than that why do you want powered wedges?  It means twice as many cables on the stage, it means more weight in the boxes that get moved the most without wheels, it means a hundred plus components to fail in the box rather than five or ten.  I get powered boxes for subs and maybe flown speakers where cable length and low impedance loads start to become an issue but not wedges.

Because powered wedges mean no big heavy amp rack to lug around, only need to run power and signal - not signal and power and speaker, no need for extra DSP/outboard, more protection from careless operators, more versatile where most powered boxes can be used as wedges and SoS, less points of failure since each wedge is self contained and one going doesn't mean two or four like an amp going (and you ultimately have the same hundreds of components), and if you're not wheeling your wedges that you're doing it wrong.

I totally get using powered wedges.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Eric Snodgrass on January 23, 2019, 11:32:01 PM
Reading that list of gear you posted it seems to me that it was about time to upgrade anyway.  What happened to you is a lousy way to start that upgrade process, but start it must. 

For the console, I would suggest an Allen&Heath SQ5 or SQ6.  Yes, the SQ5 has 16 local mic preamps, but add a DX168 digital snake box and it adds 16 more inputs, giving you 32 total mic preamps.  I really like the small form factor of the console.  The SQ6 gives you 24 faders - SQ7, 32 faders (in case you really need all 32 faders at your fingertips without going through layers).  If that console line is a bit above your budget number then take a look at the Allen&Heath QU line. 

For the wireless, at a fairly comparable price point to the AT3000, check out the Sennheiser EW100 G4 offerings.  Rock solid RF kit that should last for many years (11 years ago I recommended the Sennheiser EW100 G2 units to a local theater company and to this day they are still using them with no problems). 

For the speakers, if you are looking for a dual-purpose powered speaker, take a look (and listen) at the EV EKX 12P or ETX 12P speakers (depending on your budget number).  I like them better than the QSC K12.2 speakers.  To my ears they have a smoother response.  Oh, and they are wooden cabinets too.  EKX 12P - 1500W amp.  ETX 12P - 2000W amp.  The EKX 12P comes in at 41lbs., while the ETX 12P weighs in at 52lbs. 
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Mark Cadwallader on January 24, 2019, 01:02:49 AM
I have gone from A-T 3000 series to the Shure QLXD wireless as my transition to the new spectrum. I have both bodypacks and handhelds. The new A-T 3000 bodypacks have changed to a different connector, so my existing A-T lavs, earworn mics, and guitar cables wouldn't work with the new style. Grrr.  For me, I have better cross-rental opportunities with Shure, so I've made the switch. YMMV.

Edit:  I'm glad that only your stuff was damaged, and you were not injured.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Dave Garoutte on January 24, 2019, 02:47:53 AM
Love my RCF NX10 SMA and NX12 SMA powered monitors.  Talk to mr Pyle.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: TJ (Tom) Cornish on January 24, 2019, 08:28:01 AM
We had a small accident with our truck last week. a guy in a pickup truck tried to pass us on an icy road, lost control, hit the back of my truck and threw us in quite a bit of a spin back & forth. Got it back under control and discovered the rails inside the box had ripped off the wall and quite a bit of gear flew around.

We lost 9 of the 10 RCF ART500a speakers. The LS9/32 is trashed. Our wireless rack of 10 AT3000 wireless systems is questionable and several road cases are broken....

Now I am working with the insurance co...

I need some suggestions for replacements:

Monitors - 10 - 15 x 2 self powered
Mixer - replace the LS9/32
Wireless - What to replace the AT3000 series.

Throw me a few suggestions if you were doing this what would you get.

Thanks much

Bob Cap
Hey Bob - sorry you had the accident, but glad it was only loss of property.  We still have a bunch of ice leftover from the Dec 27th rain.

RE gear - I like Shure QLX-D wireless and A&H mixers. SQ5, 6, or 7 would be the top of my list.  The X32/M32 series while popular is nearing end of cycle, and is outclassed both in features and sound quality by the A&H gear. 

There are lots of good wedges.  I like and use Yamaha DXR and JBL SRX812p.  RE powered vs passive - powered wedges sound better per $ than passive wedges, are better protected, and if there is a failure, you replace both amp and speaker in one shot with a spare.  If an amp in a rack dies, that may or may not be easier to recover from depending on how your system is setup.  If you're like me, powered speakers get used as wedges on one show, then mains or fills on another show.  Unless something radically changes, I will never use passive utility speakers again.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Mike Monte on January 24, 2019, 09:14:59 AM
Can't resist my usual refrain.  Buy the same things you can rent more of quickly and easily.  Unless you're an entirely stand alone operation in an isolated market you will reap benefits from being able to get more wedges / speakers / amps, whatever from your competitors if you have similar inventories.  A bit less so with consoles UNLESS you use digital stage boxes then the same factors come into play.  Your inventory of course becomes much more re-rentable as well.

Other than that why do you want powered wedges?  It means twice as many cables on the stage, it means more weight in the boxes that get moved the most without wheels, it means a hundred plus components to fail in the box rather than five or ten.  I get powered boxes for subs and maybe flown speakers where cable length and low impedance loads start to become an issue but not wedges.

Maybe it's an age thing, but I am a big fan of passive monitors.....why?
- my passive monitors sound excellent - for everything that I do
- less wires on the stage (I do carry liability insurance - but have yet to file a claim - anything I can do to keep it that way, I'll do)
- outdoor performances in inclement weather: I bag them - no heat issues
I do have a couple of QSC K's that I can use in a pinch if an artist asks for one more monitor "over there" (who knows where "over there" can be..)

The only thing that I see with going the passive route is that "active wedges" are in vogue these days....  If you want your inventory to be available for cross-rentals you may be best to go with what your local/regional sound guys use.  Fortunately the local companies in my area still inventory passives along with actives.

Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Rob Spence on January 24, 2019, 09:24:09 AM
+1 on the SQ. I have an LS9-32 and I like all the faders for festivals. An SQ7 would be my go to though with the flexibility of laying out the surface, use of DCAs and matrix, an SQ6 would work. I have an SQ5 and love it.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Bob Cap on January 24, 2019, 09:57:22 AM
Better road cases...just sayin lol
Hell yes. I thought R N R Were good enough...
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Geert Friedhof on January 24, 2019, 10:02:24 AM
I would spend my money on the other, longterm items, and that's why i recommend the M32: cheap, proven, fairly rider friendly, sounds better than the ls9 and will be around for another couple of years. You get a few years to save for a higher end or some new console. The SQ series would not be my choice for several reasons, like interface, remote software and acceptance. I think there will be some competitive new consoles on the horizon. The nx12-sma is a great monitor.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Bob Cap on January 24, 2019, 10:14:39 AM
We switched over to the powered RCF boxes many years ago and have not had a problem. We have never had a box die during a performance since we switched over. I started in the game in 1971 for I have gone through many different bi-amped monitor rigs. The self powered boxes came up as the most flexible solution for us.

As far as the mixer goes...I have not looked back since we were able to dump our PM4000-48. Dumped the M7's because we had touchscreen problems. The LS9/32's have worked well. Mostly accepted with the acts we work with. I usually mix the shows we do and I do that with an iPad. But I need to have something for visiting BE's.

The AT3000's have worked well for us. No issues.

Yes, we are very fortunate that someone was looking out for us. I would hate to think what would have happened if I would have hit dry pavement while going sideways down the highway. Or another oncoming vehicle. Or the ditch. But the tie down rails in the box truck came loose and broke. Hence the gear flew around before I was able to stop.

Another day in the life of a soundguy... 
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Craig Hauber on January 24, 2019, 12:02:17 PM
We had a small accident with our truck last week. a guy in a pickup truck tried to pass us on an icy road, lost control, hit the back of my truck and threw us in quite a bit of a spin back & forth. Got it back under control and discovered the rails inside the box had ripped off the wall and quite a bit of gear flew around.

We lost 9 of the 10 RCF ART500a speakers. The LS9/32 is trashed. Our wireless rack of 10 AT3000 wireless systems is questionable and several road cases are broken....

Now I am working with the insurance co...

I need some suggestions for replacements:

Monitors - 10 - 15 x 2 self powered
Mixer - replace the LS9/32
Wireless - What to replace the AT3000 series.

Throw me a few suggestions if you were doing this what would you get.

Thanks much

Bob Cap
Had some of those plastic RCF's years ago.  Cabinets got dropped and cracked but components were still OK so I moved them to a custom built birch-ply trap cabinet  and they still work to this day.  Extracted the T-S parameters of the driver using a woofer tester and ported them optimally, I personally think they sounded better but it was subtle.  The overall look was far superior though.
So don't dumpster any undamaged parts, they were fairly high quality.

Also as far as "big heavy amp rack to lug around"  Things have changed in that world quite considerably.  4U and less than 75lbs can get you 8 biamped mixes with case and all the DSP and Dante needed.  If you jump to 8U and a bit more weight the price gets much lower. 
Either way it's not a rack of MA3600's anymore.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Michael Storey on January 24, 2019, 12:27:52 PM
LS9 > M32
Art500 > NX32, TT25-cxa
AT3000 > QLXD

This pretty much sums it up IMO. There are newer, shinier consoles available (A&H SQ series) but it's hard to beat the ubiquity of the X32/M32 platform. Guest engineers will almost certainly be familiar with it, and likely have a file for it.

As for wedges, if this is a B/C level rig i'd take a look at the Turbosound TFX series of powered coax wedges. They're hard to beat considering the recent price drop. 
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Noah D Mitchell on January 24, 2019, 12:59:56 PM
Love my RCF NX10 SMA and NX12 SMA powered monitors.  Talk to mr Pyle.


Ditto. These are fantastic. They also have PowerCon through/out connectors so you can daisy chain a few together very cleanly.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Michael Storey on January 24, 2019, 01:46:16 PM

 
......RE powered vs passive - powered wedges sound better per $ than passive wedges, are better protected, and if there is a failure, you replace both amp and speaker in one shot with a spare.  If an amp in a rack dies, that may or may not be easier to recover from depending on how your system is setup.  If you're like me, powered speakers get used as wedges on one show, then mains or fills on another show.  Unless something radically changes, I will never use passive utility speakers again.

Totally agree.

I see a lot of emphasis put on the extra cabling of powered wedges on stages, but that can be negated with packaging. Personally, I put rack mount power strips with outlets on both the front & rear in my DL32 stagebox rack. This makes it easy to use siamese cables, as power and signal comes from the same location.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Riley Casey on January 24, 2019, 02:50:53 PM
Power distro racked with mic preamps, what could possibly go wrong?   :P ::)


Totally agree.

I see a lot of emphasis put on the extra cabling of powered wedges on stages, but that can be negated with packaging. Personally, I put rack mount power strips with outlets on both the front & rear in my DL32 stagebox rack. This makes it easy to use siamese cables, as power and signal comes from the same location.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Tim McCulloch on January 24, 2019, 02:58:50 PM
Power distro racked with mic preamps, what could possibly go wrong?   :P ::)

Oh, a couple of things... don't overlook mixer (Midas Core) in the rack, too.
Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Michael Storey on January 24, 2019, 03:50:27 PM
Power distro racked with mic preamps, what could possibly go wrong?   :P ::)

Oh, a couple of things... don't overlook mixer (Midas Core) in the rack, too.

Complete with mini cams on the back! Just kidding...

I'll admit, this might have went over my head. Are you guys alluding to possible EMI/RFI issues with this setup? I've powered 6-8 wedges with relatively low power draw without issue.

Always willing to learn! 


Title: Re: Replace some gear
Post by: Frank Koenig on January 24, 2019, 05:21:35 PM
Power distro racked with mic preamps, what could possibly go wrong?   :P ::)

With all respect, I would expect this to work just fine. You're more likely to have a hum problem from powering different parts of the system from different branch circuits in a funky building. The arrangement here avoids that, at least with respect to the preamp/mixer and the powered monitors.

I use a similar arrangement with an outlet strip in the monitor amp rack (passive monitors in my case) that generally sits right underneath the preamp/mixer rack so is only inches away and have never had a problem. Mic cables and power cables are constantly intermingled on stage and that, too, never causes a problem. We use balanced signals for a reason.

--Frank