Make sure that you and your pastor are ware that in using 2 microphones for *any* single source there will be severe combfiltering (cancellations) if they are both turned on. The reason folks use 2 mic's for spoken word in live (portable) church events, conventions, press conferences, etc, is for backup. One mic is on and the other is off but it may be turned on if the first one fails.
I never specify or provide 2 microphones for pulpits and other permanently installed applications/systems because the equipment we have available today is very reliable.
My current favorite gooseneck mic is the Flex from Earthworks. Second to that is the similar device from Clock Audio. Model C34E/SR. They both sound *very* natural and exhibit very good cardioid response. I recommend the longest goosenecks so that they can be positioned appropriately for any talker.
www.earthworksaudio.comwww.clockaudio.comBe aware that if your podium/pulpit is not built solidly it may contribute mechanically induced rumble into the mic. For this reason I often use an isolating device such as the Clock Audio Model SM75 and I also employ a channel high-pass filter.