When I need to get some isolation from a noisy band, and when the player is willing to play with a fully closed lid, and when the owner won't scream at me for the tape (as Peter said), I use two SM-91's (the Beta 91's are a bit heavier and need a regular mic cable which is also heavier than the SM-91's wires).
One is placed facing the player, slightly below the middle note on the piano and away from the player just past the hammers by a bit.
The other is placed roughly near the higher end of the low strings, perpendicular to the low strings facing away from the highs and towards the lower strings.
Once I got the spots it hasn't seemed like I've had to monkey around with them once they're in place, which would be a pain since you have to pretty securely tape both mics and cables to the lid. Gravity is not your friend in this situation and it's embarrassing to say the least if something falls down at any time.
With two mics you can somewhat season to taste.