Chuck Simon wrote on Sun, 07 November 2010 18:57 |
Bob Josjor wrote on Mon, 08 November 2010 00:05 |
Seth Hochberg wrote on Sat, 06 November 2010 23:14 | There are good wood PA cabs, and there are plenty of bad ones. There are good plastic PA cabs, and plenty of bad ones of those, too.
|
We have a winner!!!
There are lots of general statements that may apply (wood is heavy, plastic flexs too much, etc) but the above statement is the only truly correct one.
|
Really? What are some of the really good plastic ones? Who is using them?
|
Sound Image had plenty of really good touring cabinets made of plastic, though not the usual plastics. They use foam core, covered with glass fiber, similar to boat construction.
Wood is a lousy material to make cabinets from, as it is resonant.
Plywood alternates layers of wood, grain running at 90 degrees opposite in each layer, making it far less resonant, so it is a good cabinet material. The glue that holds plywood together is basically plastic.
Baltic Birch is great for cabinet building because it has more plys and lots of glue.
Plastics have the advantage of being able to mold bracing and compound curves into the material, but that greatly increases the cost of the mold, and the difficulty in injection, making it very expensive relative to a plywood construction.
Proper bracing can eliminate lots of material, wood or plastic, and can net better sounding lighter results.
However, that bracing adds construction time, complexity and expense, which few are willing to pay for.
Art Welter