Sound Reinforcement - Forums for Live Sound Professionals - Your Displayed Name Must Be Your Real Full Name To Post In The Live Sound Forums > Pro AV FUD Forum Archive

Video Playback

<< < (3/3)

Silas Pradetto:
Bennett Prescott wrote on Tue, 02 November 2010 15:22
  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-bandwidth_Digital_Content_ Protection

That laptop will probably not allow DVD video to be played on a device it does not control.


Isn't that what I said?  

Silas Pradetto { wrote on Mon, 25 October 2010 12:42
Very likely it's a copy protection thing.

Mike Tomei, CTS:
No, if he's using a VGA connection, then I don't think HDCP is the culprit.  I agree with Christopher on this one.  We used to run into this problem all the time.  One of our IT techs wrote up something on how to fix it, but it's too long to post on here.  PM me if you would like me to email you a copy.

Here's a quick summary of what he wrote up:
"There are two simple ways to work around this display issue.
1. If possible, set both the laptop display and the external display (monitor, projector, etc) as primary display devices.  In some cases only one output device can be set to primary.  In these cases, the external device should be set to primary.  The laptop display will become secondary and its video output will inherently be blank instead.  
2. Using the display toggle function key, set the video output to external only.  The laptop display will be inactive and the external display will become inherently primary."

Mike Tomei

Silas Pradetto:
Mike Tomei, CTS wrote on Tue, 02 November 2010 15:58
No, if he's using a VGA connection, then I don't think HDCP is the culprit.  I agree with Christopher on this one.  We used to run into this problem all the time.  One of our IT techs wrote up something on how to fix it, but it's too long to post on here.  PM me if you would like me to email you a copy.

Here's a quick summary of what he wrote up:
"There are two simple ways to work around this display issue.
1. If possible, set both the laptop display and the external display (monitor, projector, etc) as primary display devices.  In some cases only one output device can be set to primary.  In these cases, the external device should be set to primary.  The laptop display will become secondary and its video output will inherently be blank instead.  
2. Using the display toggle function key, set the video output to external only.  The laptop display will be inactive and the external display will become inherently primary."

Mike Tomei



I didn't say anything about HDCP (we're talking about VGA), and what you just described is what Bennett said better than I did: That it's the computer not letting you output video to an unknown device, so you can't record it.

Stupid, I know.

VGA is easy; HDCP is the bane of my existence.

Trevor Ludwig:
I've run into this multiple times with laptops at the university that I worked for.  The problem wasn't an uncontrolled VGA, HDCP or any of that.  Christopher Dean had it right in my situation.  The video card simply could not display on multiple monitors simultaneously.  The biggest problem for these situations is video embedded into powerpoint presentations.  When the video slide would come up, you could see the border, and text, but there would be a black spot where the video should be, but only on one source.

The correction to this is one of two things.  Either you can set your Primary monitor to be the Projector, which will then display the video being played, but only on the projector.  If in a powerpoint presentation, if the video is not fullscreen, you will still have full view of everything else, but there will be a black box where the video should be.  (this was the option I had to use more often than not, as the laptop display was a reference for the presenter.)  Or you can simply set the display to projector only, in which case the video should display fine.

If neither of these situations work...you have yourself an entirely different problem.

Let us know how it works out for you next time.  I'm curious to know how this is solved.

tl

Nate Strickland:
Agreed with what Chris, Trevor, and others have said.  This is not a copy protection thing.  

Most inexpensive video cards only have the hardware to do one video overlay at a time.  Which screen it goes to is usually determined by which one you set up to be 'primary' in the configuration.  Sometimes 'clone mode' will send the overlay to both screens, but not always -- I think this depends on the exact implementation, i.e. where in the graphics card the split is taken.  Occasionally, you'll run into a laptop that due to really crappy firmware, won't let you set the external display to be primary, and thus, the only way to get video playback on the external display is to disable the internal display.  

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page

Go to full version