ProSoundWeb Community

Sound Reinforcement - Forums for Live Sound Professionals - Your Displayed Name Must Be Your Real Full Name To Post In The Live Sound Forums => SR Forum Archives => LAB Lounge FUD Forum Archive => Topic started by: Mike Constable on August 08, 2007, 11:01:25 AM

Title: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Mike Constable on August 08, 2007, 11:01:25 AM
I currently have two pairs of single 18" w-bins.  I am planning on upgrading my mains and would like to try the array route.  I am on a fixed budget and was considering JBL or PV.  I can probably only afford two boxes per side to start.  Would this be enough for bar/club scene and medium sized outdoor stuff?  I would say audiences range from 100-1000.  Just looking for some information and opinions on this potential setup.
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: A Thomas Lamb on August 08, 2007, 11:11:55 AM
You should read the reviews of the versarray in the road test section of the forum. 2 box's a side is not gonna do it outside for a 1000 people your gonna need more bottoms too. Good luck!
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: E. Lee Dickinson on August 08, 2007, 11:31:30 AM
Mike,

If you're trying to get in to expandable arrays, the Versarray is probably a better starting point than the VRX. This is hard for me to say, as I went the VRX route!

The VRX are a fixed curvature 'linear array,' -- if you are trying to use multiple cabinets to shape the wavefront for long throw to the back of the house, VRX aren't going to work. If you want to be angle a ribbon of speakers just right for coverage in your venue, the VRX aren't going to work.

The Peaveys are cheaper, too... I kindof wish I had gone that route. I settled on VRX because I like JBL, because I got a good deal on an all Harmon setup (amps, processors, cabinets), and because the companies around here also have VRX, and we exchange so frequently we don't even bother invoicing anymore.

I am about ready for a 'real' line array, though, and the Versarray might just be it.

Thinks I like about the VRX? Very simple deployment in a lot of configurations. Multiple pipe pockets for different angles on a stand. Setup with an upward curving ribbon for stadium seating coverage from a ground stack has proved more useful than I imagined it'd be. They sound great.
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Tom faderjockey Brandis on August 08, 2007, 12:14:15 PM
Mike, I would at the very least go with 3 VR112's per side. Now, here's the problem. If you plan to use your existing subs how do you plan to mount or hang the VR112's? Peavey has a ground stack which mounts to a VR218 sub. Please take into consideration that the sub weighs close to 200#'s and makes for a very stable platform for the three VR112's. You could use the mount on your subs if A: your subs have enough room to mount the ground stack kit to and B: you make sure you strap both subs together for stability. Even then you may have to weigh them down depending on the weight of your subs. Each VR112 weighs 50#'s.

Just some food for thought.

I'm a happy owner of a Versarray system. If you're not far from Baltimore I'd be more then happy to demo it to you.

Cheers,

Tom in Baltimore
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Jeff Babcock on August 08, 2007, 12:29:57 PM
Mike,
As others have said, don't expect 2 boxes/side to give you enough overall output on larger gigs.  It would work fine for smaller or low volume gigs, just don't expect to get "line array" effect with that many boxes.  And really you can't expect to do those size of shows anyway with your existing subs.  Keep in mind also the amp requirements for these.  They are fairly power hungry for their size so once you get into 3 or more per side plus subs you're going to be hard pressed to run without a distro.  If you want to keep to a small number of boxes with high output you might be better served by something like Community SLS920's or similar.  Those will give more output and be easier on your amplifier requirements.

The Versarray are great boxes but probably not what you really need.

Jeff
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Gerry Tacker on August 08, 2007, 12:42:30 PM
If you are doing ground stack P.A. check out the Danley Sh-50
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Jeff Babcock on August 08, 2007, 12:45:07 PM
SH50's are a great box but based on what has been said already I think they will be well out of his price range.
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Mike Constable on August 09, 2007, 03:37:38 PM
Thanks for all of the responses.  I am still in the thinking stage of upgrading and I really appreciate that offer for the Peavey versarray demo.  I have been trying to mull over financing for the versarray but may have to go a cheaper route with a ground stacked trap system.
Currently I have two three way cabs stuffed with all Eminence
PSD2002
beta 12"
Kappa Pro 15"
I was thinking of getting more of the birch boxes and use 2-4 boxes a side for mains and use my existing 4 w-bins and either add bins or dual 18s.  Of course I will be adding amps and possibly thinking of PV cs series.
Thoughts?
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Jeff Babcock on August 10, 2007, 12:37:46 PM
What's the pattern on your existing boxes?  Building more of those and grouping them may just take you into major comb filter territory unless they're on a narrower horn.  And even still, how is their pattern control overall (what design are these cabs based on?). That design might not have been created with intentions to array well... also is the mid driver horn-loaded and if so what is the horn shape?  Also, sounds like you are talking about mixing double 18's with your w-bins... DON'T... mixing bass cabs is a no-no

Cheers
Jeff
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Tate_Tullis on August 10, 2007, 12:54:14 PM
ok, so i talked to the local sound guy here and he said stay away from both of them. He said that the Peavey ones have no output at all but the VRX are a little better. I of course have no idea becuase ive never used both. Anyone know. would either of the series work for clubs with 3 per side, maybe 400 people indoors to 700 outdoors?
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Tony "T" Tissot on August 10, 2007, 01:08:22 PM
Tate Tullis wrote on Fri, 10 August 2007 09:54

ok, so i talked to the local sound guy here and he said stay away from both of them.
That's a bit broad?
Quote:

He said that the Peavey ones have no output at all but the VRX are a little better.
No output? That's just nonsense
Quote:

 I of course have no idea becuase ive never used both. Anyone know. would either of the series work for clubs with 3 per side, maybe 400 people indoors to 700 outdoors?
I am certain that they both would - although the number of cabinets has to be based on the coverage and SPL. At that size audience - a "traditional" stack configuration is probably much more cost-effective.
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Tom faderjockey Brandis on August 10, 2007, 01:11:46 PM
Tate, tell your local guy he's full of it. I of course don't have any experience with the JBL stuff, however, I have a Versarray system installed at a club that has a capacity of 500. I use a single hang of four boxes in the center and two QW3's for front fill along with 4 VR218's centered. It will rip your head off.

We have some very knowledgeable and experienced guys here on LAB that have used the VR system and love it. I don't know what your local guys setup is, but if it's 3 boxes per side and he's trying to do 2000 people, well what do expect, that's not enough rig for the gig. Look at the road test section on the Versarray. Lot's of input from many there.

Tom in Baltimore
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Rob Burgess on August 10, 2007, 01:12:48 PM
Tate Tullis wrote on Fri, 10 August 2007 12:54

ok, so i talked to the local sound guy here and he said stay away from both of them.


Might I suggest you get a second opinion?  Better yet, get a first opinion that isn't completely full of shit.  Then get a second opinion.


Tate Tullis wrote on Fri, 10 August 2007 12:54

 He said that the Peavey ones have no output at all


Yeah, they're being used at Ozzfest because they suck and don't put out much sound.

--
Rob
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Tate_Tullis on August 10, 2007, 01:16:31 PM
[quote title=Tony "T" Tissot wrote on Fri, 10 August 2007 12:08]
Tate Tullis wrote on Fri, 10 August 2007 09:54

ok, so i talked to the local sound guy here and he said stay away from both of them.
That's a bit broad?

yea, theres only one big sound company here. but im still looking at the Versarray system. i can always expand it too which is a thing i like. well i guess i can expand anything but whatever  Razz
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Mac Kerr on August 10, 2007, 01:16:35 PM
Tate Tullis wrote on Fri, 10 August 2007 12:54

ok, so i talked to the local sound guy here and he said stay away from both of them. He said that the Peavey ones have no output at all but the VRX are a little better.
Well, there you have it. Is there reason for more discussion?  
Quote:

 I of course have no idea becuase ive never used both. Anyone know. would either of the series work for clubs with 3 per side, maybe 400 people indoors to 700 outdoors?
The JBL VRX and Peavey Versarry are 2 different types of speakers. The Versarry is a line array element, the VRX is a vertically arrayable speaker with a coverage patter of 100deg horizontal by 15deg vertical. To use 3 VRX, you have to want a vertical coverage pattern of 45deg, which is 3 times the 15deg per box coverage. You can only array the boxes at these fixed 15deg increments. What has become known as a "line array" is a large array of smaller elements that achieves vertical pattern control at progressively lower frequencies as the length of the array increases. It is also possible with most (if not all) "line arrays" to control the vertical coverage pattern of mid and high frequencies buy changing the shape of the array. With 3 elements per side there will be very little low frequency pattern control from either of these speakers. Since the VRX is a 12" low frequency driver with 3 horn drivers with a 3/4" throat, and the Versarry is a 12" low frequency driver with a ribbon high frequency driver, and they are 100deg and 90deg by 15deg nominal coverage respectively, I wouldn't expect there to be huge differences in performance in arrays of 3, although the PV will give you more vertical aiming capability.

Mac
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Jeff Babcock on August 10, 2007, 01:18:17 PM
Sounds like the local sound guy is talking out of his "you know where", trying to make you think he knows something when he obviously hasn't got a clue.  The VRX are "a little better"...  Laughing  Yes they MUST be "a little better" because everybody knows that a JBL logo makes it sound better than anything Peavey could ever make before you even actually hear the product!.... Laughing   What a joke, this guy must really know his stuff.
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Alfred_Mapanao on August 10, 2007, 03:40:38 PM
He must also work at Guitar Center
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Don Boomer on August 11, 2007, 08:15:47 AM
Are you still having an open house/LAB party there?
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Doug Fowler on August 12, 2007, 01:55:48 PM
Quote:

ok, so i talked to the local sound guy here and he said stay away from both of them


Time to find a new guy.....
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Tom faderjockey Brandis on August 12, 2007, 09:15:57 PM
Sure am Don. You making the trip? Love to have ya.

Tom
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Don Lanier on August 13, 2007, 04:29:58 AM
I beg to differ and whomever said the Peavey Versarray has "NO OUTPUT" is full of Doo-Doo, the box rocks and loudly, Ive seen setups of these that had very little drop off of SPL at very very long distances, a single array of 8 in the middle of a parking lot covered a football field in length easily, cleanly and with very little loss of SPL. Im not easily impressed by all the cheap talk I want to hear it, and thats what sold me on this system.

It just gets back to bashing gear( Its Peavey ) instead of stating facts, statistics and real information, opinion is just  your opinion, But dont quote some sound guy that has never heard or seen the system. Go to Ozzfest and tell them that the system has no output !! The Versarray is an impressive product that does a very good job and allows you to have the true line array, with Ribbons. The VRX due to its design is limited in its ability to use more then three boxes, unless your using as fill for the cheap seats or straight down.

For the users that need these and want to have this type of system its a very cost effective way to enter the Line Array market. Performance is there to match best of all its Affordable, Scalable, Flyable gear. Very Happy
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Bob Leonard on August 14, 2007, 10:56:36 AM
Don,
Very true indeed. I'm pretty well known as being brand loyal to JBL. I don't know why, Rolling Eyes but that being the case I had an opportunity to listen to a Versarray the other day a I was very impressed with the volume, build quality and tone. I'll also say that they give the VRX a good run for the money and it would be a tough decision to make in a side by side comparison test. I tend to like the sound of the JBL drivers a little more, but that's always going to be subjective and based on the listening individual. There ya go, I tried to disguise it, but I like the Peavey system.
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Jeff Babcock on August 14, 2007, 11:59:44 AM
There you have it folks, even Bob likes it!   Shocked

See, the buzz about these isn't all talk!  These fill the gap that VRX leaves once you get beyond 3 boxes/side.  Not to mention they are considerably cheaper.  I'm just looking for an excuse to pick some up.  Apparently the subs are no slouch either.
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Ryan McLeod on August 14, 2007, 01:57:04 PM
Jeff - you can help me lift mine any time you'd like.

Lift on three....... Smile


R.
Title: Re: JBL VRX or PV Versarray
Post by: Jeff Babcock on August 14, 2007, 04:47:47 PM
Well I didn't quite mean it that way.... Laughing  but hey sometime when I'm in your area maybe I can catch a show you're doing and get to hear the full rig.... I haven't heard a large hang of these yet, just a pair.